A-Car Auto Rental

- 66 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point, NY 11715

For residents across New York, especially those on Long Island, the need for reliable and specific vehicle rentals can arise for a multitude of reasons. Whether it's planning a group trip to a state park, commuting within Suffolk County, or simply needing a temporary ride while your personal vehicle is in the shop, finding a trusted local car rental service is essential. In Blue Point, A-Car Auto Rental stands as a unique option, particularly highlighted for its offerings in larger passenger vans and its commitment to local customer service.

A-Car Auto Rental distinguishes itself as a local, independent car rental provider, often prioritizing direct, personalized interactions over a heavily digital presence. While their website may be outdated, as noted by customer feedback, the core of their service appears to lie in direct communication and competitive pricing. This approach often resonates with New Yorkers who prefer a more personal touch and appreciate value. A-Car aims to provide a range of vehicles, with a particular strength in accommodating larger groups through their 15-person van rentals, a service not always readily available at every rental branch.

A-Car Auto Rental is located at 66 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point, NY 11715, USA. This address places it conveniently on Montauk Highway, a primary route stretching across Long Island. This central location in Blue Point ensures good accessibility for residents throughout Suffolk County, including nearby towns such as Patchogue, Bayport, Sayville, and even those a bit further like Islip and Bohemia.

Being situated on a well-known highway makes the branch easy to find and reach, reducing the complexities of navigating to a rental office. For New Yorkers needing a vehicle for local use, or those looking to start a journey directly from the South Shore of Long Island, this location offers a practical and straightforward option. While the online information might be limited, the physical accessibility of the branch is a key advantage for local customers.

• Diverse Vehicle Fleet: A-Car Auto Rental offers a selection of vehicles, with a notable specialization in larger capacity rentals. Their inventory includes:
  • Cars (starting at competitive daily rates).
  • Mini Vans.
  • Cargo Vans.
  • 12 and 15 Passenger Vans: This is a significant highlight, offering solutions for large groups, sports teams, church outings, or family events across New York.
• Competitive Rates: Customers report that A-Car offers "best rates for comparable rentals," indicating a strong focus on affordability. They advertise car rentals starting from $29.95/day and specific rates for vans (e.g., Mini-Vans at $89.95/day w/100 miles, 12 or 15 Passenger Vans at $189.95/day w/100 miles).
• Flexible Rental Periods: They offer both daily and weekly rental packages. For instance, Mini-Vans are $549.95/week w/700 miles, and 12 or 15 Passenger Vans are $1199.95/weekly w/700 miles.
• MacArthur Airport Pickup and Drop-off: A key convenience for Long Island travelers, A-Car provides services to and from MacArthur Airport (ISP), though a 2-day minimum rental might apply for airport pick-up/drop-off.
• Low Mileage, Late Model Cars: A-Car strives to provide "Low Mileage, Late Model Cars," aiming for a reliable and comfortable driving experience.
• Included Mileage: Rates typically include a set amount of mileage (e.g., 100 miles/day for vans, 700 miles/week for weekly van rentals), with additional mileage available at a per-mile charge (e.g., $0.35/mile for cars, $0.45/mile for 12/15 passenger vans).
• Replacement Rate/No Extra Insurance Cost: The website mentions a "Replacement Rate/No Extra Insurance Cost," which might indicate favorable terms for those needing a rental due to vehicle repairs (it's essential to confirm specifics directly).

• Competitive Pricing: A-Car is praised for having "the best rates for comparable rentals," making it an attractive option for budget-conscious New Yorkers.
• Clean and Well-Maintained Vehicles: Customers consistently report that rented vehicles are "clean inside and out," have a "full tank of gas," and "ran great." This is particularly highlighted for the 15-person van.
• Friendly and Clear Communication (from specific staff): Tim, a staff member, received positive feedback for being "friendly and explained everything clearly" both on the phone and in person.
• Strong Recommendation from Satisfied Customers: Positive reviews enthusiastically "definitely recommend A-Car Rental."
• Specialization in Passenger Vans: The availability and positive experience with the 15-person van are a significant draw for groups, a niche not always filled by larger chains.
• Outdated Website and Limited Online Information: A recurring negative point is the "outdated" and largely uninformative website, which can hinder initial research and booking attempts. The business itself stated the site owner "locked them out."
• Potential for Poor Phone Service: One review specifically noted being "treated badly for asking questions" on the phone due to the lack of website information, suggesting inconsistency in phone interactions or frustration from staff due to website limitations.
• Information Accessibility Challenge: The lack of online information can be a "disgrace" for some customers, leading to a frustrating experience before even reaching the rental stage.

Address: 66 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point, NY 11715, USA

Phone: (631) 363-5300

Mobile Phone: +1 631-363-5300

For residents across New York, particularly those on Long Island, A-Car Auto Rental in Blue Point offers a distinct and potentially highly suitable option for their car rental needs. Its convenient location on Montauk Highway ensures easy accessibility from various communities within Suffolk County, making it a practical choice for immediate local needs or for starting a trip.

What truly sets A-Car Auto Rental apart, and makes it particularly suitable for New Yorkers, are its competitive rates and its specialization in larger passenger vans. For families, groups, or organizations needing a 12 or 15-person van, A-Car appears to be a go-to local solution, offering vehicles that are reported to be "clean inside and out" and running "great." The emphasis on "low mileage, late model cars" also contributes to a reliable rental experience.

While the outdated website and some initial phone interaction challenges are noted by customers, the positive experiences consistently highlight the quality of the vehicles and the helpfulness of specific staff members like Tim, who are praised for being "friendly and explained everything clearly." This suggests that for those willing to engage directly, the benefits of competitive pricing and a well-maintained fleet, particularly for specialized vehicles like passenger vans, outweigh the initial communication hurdles. For New Yorkers prioritizing value and the ability to rent larger vehicles from a local, customer-focused establishment, A-Car Auto Rental in Blue Point remains a highly recommended choice, proving that sometimes, the best local finds are discovered through direct interaction and word-of-mouth rather than glossy online presentations.

A-Car Auto Rental

66 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point, NY 11715, USA